|
Case Presentation Evaluation
TEAM MEMBERS:
Summarize the team's statement of problem:
List the team's alternative solutions:
Summarize the team's solution:
Letter
Grade |
|
| _____ |
Problem Identification:
Is it clear? Is it reasonable for this situation? Does
it cover the sorts of issues raised in the case?
|
| _____ |
Situation Analysis:
Was enough relevent information provided that would enable the assessment
of alternative courses of action?
Was irrelevant information presented?
|
| _____ |
Analysis of Alternative Strategies:
Were the most relevent and reasonable alternatives presented?
Was the analysis of sufficient breadth and depth?
|
| _____ |
Solution:
Does it answer the problem identified by this team? Is it clear?
Are you persuaded that the team's recommendation should be accepted?
|
| _____ |
Oral Presentation:
Is it well organized? Is it of a professional nature? Would
you hire this team?
|
All things considered, what overall score would you give this
team?
|
Letter
Grade
|
Percent
Grade
|
|
_____
|
_____
|
To receive a score in the "A" range, the presentation must be considered by
the professor to be "good enough for the real world." A score in the
"B" range will be assigned to presentations that have minor problems, such
as the need for clarification in a statement of problem. Lower scores
will be assigned to presentations which have problems that are not
so minor, such as an inability of the group to adequately clarify a
statement of problem during questions associated with the presentation.
|